Have you ever felt a gnawing disconnect between your company’s ambitious sustainability pledges and the quiet apathy or even cynicism that is brewing among your workforce?
You’re not alone.
While companies invest billions in Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) and sustainability initiatives and meticulous sustainability reporting, nearly half of all organisations cite a lack of employee engagement as their primary obstacle to achieving their sustainability goals. This presents a profound paradox, revealing a dangerous imbalance where external validation often takes precedence over internal commitment.
The Quiet Struggle Nobody Talks About: Engagement Deficit
Suppose you’ve ever felt like your carefully crafted sustainability/ESG messages are disregarded or that your employees “tune out” during sustainability presentations. In that case, you’re witnessing the subtle but powerful symptoms of a deeper problem. Here’s what we keep hearing from leaders and what employees are quietly experiencing:
- Skepticism and Cynicism: Employees possess an insider’s view and are acutely sensitive to “greenwashing” and corporate hypocrisy.1 Nearly half (49%) of employees suspect that their employers are involved in greenwashing,2 which creates a foundation of distrust that undermines all sustainability communications. They develop “fine-tuned antennae” for tokenism, viewing all corporate communication on the topic with suspicion.3 56% of employees believe most employers only talk about ESG ‘for show’. 4
- Frustration and Powerlessness: Many passionate employees who were initially excited by their company’s stated mission feel a deep sense of betrayal when they see a lack of genuine commitment or follow-through.5 Only 15% of employees say they have responsibility for or take part in sustainability efforts, which leads to feelings of being left out of meaningful environmental actions despite constant corporate messaging.6 One sustainability professional expressed frustration that their expertise was used for show rather than creating real change, saying, “I feel that our overall impact on the real issues of sustainability is often minor. It feels like we’re just scratching the surface while the deeper systemic problems remain unaddressed.”7
- Confusion and Information Overload: The sustainability field is rife with acronyms, including GHG, LCA, GRI, CDP, SASB, and IIRC, which create a significant barrier to understanding.8 Employees report feeling overwhelmed by complex ESG frameworks that seem disconnected from their daily work, often leading to mental shutdown when sustainability topics arise.8
- Anxiety and Moral Injury: Younger generations, in particular, are deeply worried about climate change (31% of 16-24 year olds are apprehensive).9 Yet, they often feel their employers’ sustainability efforts are inadequate or merely performative, creating a painful disconnect between personal environmental anxiety and professional reality. This can manifest as “moral injury”—a psychological wound from being complicit in actions that violate deeply held ethical beliefs.10
- Burnout and Isolation: Sustainability professionals themselves are facing an epidemic of burnout, with 62% experiencing it in the past year, and 96% of climate professionals reporting ‘high’ or ‘very high’ levels of burnout.11 This often stems from carrying the psychological burden of climate anxiety while working within systems that resist meaningful change, coupled with understaffing and a lack of organizational influence.12
This “engagement deficit” carries a staggering cost: disengaged employees cost the global economy an astonishing $8.8 trillion in lost productivity, equivalent to 9% of the world’s GDP.13 For ESG initiatives, this means environmental goals lack the workforce commitment essential for their successful implementation.14
What’s Really Going On Beneath the Surface: Lack of Employee Engagement
The symptoms described above are not isolated incidents; they are the direct result of deep-seated, systemic flaws in how organisations design, communicate, and lead their Sustainability/ESG strategies.
- The External Stakeholder Obsession: A primary systemic flaw is the overwhelming focus on external stakeholders, such as investors, regulators, and consumers. Companies direct immense resources towards satisfying these external demands, often neglecting their most critical stakeholder group: their own workforce. This leads to the dangerous trap of “outsourcing trust,” where organisations believe external validations, such as B-Corp certifications or high ESG ratings, will serve as credible proxies for genuine commitment. However, the trust of an employee is built on perceived authenticity, leadership integrity, and consistency between words and actions—it cannot be outsourced.3,5
- The Top-Down Trap and Relevance Gap: Many ESG strategies are conceived in the boardroom and handed down as mandates, rooted in a compliance mindset. This top-down structure inherently prevents genuine employee ownership, as initiatives imposed from above are perceived as just another corporate obligation. Furthermore, broad sustainability goals, such as “achieving net-zero emissions,” often fail to resonate because employees cannot answer a simple question: “What does this have to do with me?” A comprehensive 2024 PwC study found that employees are primarily motivated by their own well-being and financial security, considering ESG policies only after these fundamental needs are met.15-17
- The Communication Void and Leadership Paradox: A startling 71% of employees who had not participated in their company’s sustainability program reported they were unaware it even existed. Companies often excel at communicating ESG goals externally but neglect an equally robust internal strategy. Compounding this is the “say-do gap”—the perceived inconsistency between what leaders say and what the company actually does. If leaders do not visibly prioritise sustainability in their daily decisions and resource allocations, employees conclude it’s not a real priority. This includes what some call the “complicity of loving kindness,” where companies focus on easy, superficial actions while avoiding the hard work required for true systemic change.3,19,20
The shift from the loosely defined Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) era (pre-2015) to the more rigorous, data-driven ESG framework (post-2015) has actually amplified these issues. While ESG brought measurability, it also made any hypocrisy or gap between words and actions far more visible to knowledgeable insiders, such as employees.21-23 Concurrently, the rise of a purpose-driven workforce, particularly Millennials and Gen Z, means that purpose and value alignment are no longer perks but primary demands. They see themselves as stakeholders with a right to expect their employer to be a force for good. This has led to a new accountability, with employee activism emerging as a formidable internal check on corporate promises.3,24
Where Capability Training and Strategic Alignment Change the Game
The path forward requires a radical rebalancing: a strategic pivot from an “outside-in” approach, focused on satisfying external raters, to an “inside-out” transformation that fosters authentic commitment from within. This is where capability-building becomes a critical strategic lever.
We’ve seen firsthand how transforming internal capabilities can bridge this gap. For too long, ESG training has been a “check-the-box” compliance exercise.25 But when Learning & Development (L&D) is elevated to a strategic partner, it cultivates “deep ESG fluency” across the entire organisation.25,26 This means employees can apply their understanding of sustainability/ESG to their specific roles, make informed decisions, and actively contribute to achieving sustainability goals.
Consider this:
- A home furnishings retailer, Room & Board, needed to advance its product circularity goals, but its internal teams lacked the technical knowledge. Instead of outsourcing, they implemented a “train and do” approach with custom workshops for a cross-functional team. This not only solved the immediate problem but built lasting internal capability, leading to a robust ESG governance strategy.27 This demonstrates how targeted, role-specific learning and development (L&D), utilizing engaging methodologies such as workshops and case studies, can directly empower teams to drive core business and sustainability objectives.
- A major manufacturing company faced a similar challenge, where employees lacked a consistent understanding of sustainability concepts, which hindered their reporting and operational goals. Through tailored, interactive training focused on real-world scenarios, they built manufacturing/ESG literacy, established a shared vocabulary, and helped employees connect high-level sustainability/ESG issues directly to their operational roles. This resulted in a measurable increase in employee confidence and more meaningful engagement.
These examples showcase how a commitment to authenticity, courageous communication, and empowering involvement can transform an organisation. Leaders must lead by example, visibly embedding ESG into their daily decisions and resource allocation, demonstrating “proof over promises.”28 Communication must be radically transparent, sharing not only successes but also setbacks, fostering two-way dialogue, and acting on feedback. Most powerfully, organisations must shift from delegation to co-creation, empowering grassroots movements and involving employees in goal-setting from the outset.29,30 By making sustainability “everyone’s job”—not by decree, but by fostering shared ownership—you unlock passionate commitment.
Finally, making sustainability/ESG personal and tangible involves translating broad goals into specific roles (e.g., how an engineer designs, a facilities manager implements, or an office worker contributes). This begins by prioritising the “S” pillar—fair pay, psychological safety, and professional development—to build foundational trust and goodwill before engaging on broader environmental goals. And remember, what gets rewarded gets done: integrate sustainability objectives into performance reviews and incentivise leadership with ESG-related Key Performance Indicators (KPIs).19
If You’re Facing This—Here’s What to Ask or Try Next
If you recognise these struggles within your own organisation, here are a few critical questions and steps to consider:
- Are we consistently communicating our ESG/sustainability journey—including challenges and setbacks—internally, before making any external announcements?
Trust is built by sharing the full, honest picture, not just polished narratives.
- How are we truly empowering our employees to contribute to ESG, beyond just asking them to participate in isolated events?
Consider establishing employee-led green committees or Employee Resource Groups (ERGs) and providing them with genuine autonomy and resources.
- Is our Learning & Development function strategically positioned and resourced to build deep, role-specific ESG fluency across the organisation, or is it still a “check-the-box” compliance exercise?
Elevating L&D can transform awareness into actionable capability.
Closing Reflection for Sustainability and Business Leaders
The future of Sustainability/ESG will not be defined by the quality of a company’s sustainability report, but by the quality of its culture. When you stop attempting to “outsource trust” to external ratings and instead invest in building genuine commitment from within, you unlock a powerful virtuous cycle.
An authentic, employee-centric ESG strategy fosters the trust that fuels engagement, which in turn drives superior ESG outcomes from the grassroots up. Ultimately, a deeply engaged workforce becomes your most formidable ESG asset—your most credible storytellers, most passionate innovators, and most effective agents of change. This ability to mobilise the collective energy and commitment of your people towards a shared purpose is, without doubt, the most enduring and inimitable competitive advantage of all.
Close the Sustainability Capability Gap—With Action, Not Intention
True sustainability transformation demands more than good intentions. It requires measurable capabilities, strategic integration, and leadership alignment.
Ready to turn sustainability into your greatest competitive advantage?
🔹 Explore corporate training for your teams
🔹 Book 1:1 coaching to sharpen your strategy and impact
🔹 Or start with a free discovery call to build your roadmapYour next move begins now—because capability establishes credibility.
Source
[1] Employees’ Response to Corporate Greenwashing – Scholarship@Western, accessed on July 17, 2025, https://ir.lib.uwo.ca/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1076&context=mospub
[2] Brands in Motion: Engaging employees is key to overcoming ‘green fatigue’—companies must make sustainability commitments real to ignite change, accessed on July 17, 2025, https://www.agilitypr.com/pr-news/public-relations/brands-in-motion-engaging-employees-is-key-to-overcoming-green-fatigue-companies-must-make-sustainability-commitments-real-to-ignite-long-term-change/
[3] The Importance of Employee Engagement in Sustainability | by Christopher Nial – Medium, accessed on July 17, 2025, https://medium.com/purpose-and-social-impact/the-importance-of-employee-engagement-in-sustainability-a1c32c3603ab
[4] ESG U-turn ‘risks damaging employer-employee relationships’, accessed on July 17, 2025, https://hrreview.co.uk/hr-news/strategy-news/esg-u-turn-risks-damaging-employer-employee-relationships/380347
[5] Employees disengaged with your ESG commitments? The answer …, accessed on July 17, 2025,https://www.hrgrapevine.com/content/article/2024-02-06-why-a-communication-strategy-is-key-to-employee-engagement-with-sustainability-commitments
[6] Employees to executives: Make sustainability commitments real, accessed on July 17, 2025, https://www.campaignasia.com/article/employees-to-executives-make-sustainability-commitments-real/484575
[7] Struggling with Corporate Sustainability: Looking for Insights and …, accessed on July 17, 2025,https://www.reddit.com/r/sustainability/comments/1ftp8qk/struggling_with_corporate_sustainability_looking/
[8] 9 Reasons Your Sustainability Communications Fail, accessed on July 17, 2025, https://www.environmentenergyleader.com/stories/9-reasons-your-sustainability-communications-fail,8727
[9] 5 ways to engage employees with your sustainability communications, accessed on July 17, 2025, https://somethingbig.co.uk/engage-employees-with-sustainability-communications/
[10] Employee Green Values and Greenwashing: Mediating Role of Person-Organization Fit, accessed on July 17, 2025, https://journals.aom.org/doi/10.5465/AMPROC.2025.10560abstract
[11] Burnout Is Killing Climate Progress—Here’s How We Fix It, accessed on July 17, 2025, https://cleantechnica.com/2025/04/14/burnout-is-killing-climate-progress-heres-how-we-fix-it/
[12] Burnout rises among sustainability professionals as employers fail to invest in green skills, accessed on July 17, 2025, https://instituteofsustainabilitystudies.com/insights/news-analysis/burnout-rising-as-employers-fail-to-invest-in-green-skills/
[13] 15 Employee Engagement Statistics You Need To Know In 2025, accessed on July 17, 2025, https://peoplemanagingpeople.com/employee-retention/employee-engagement-statistics/
[14] State of the Global Workplace Report – Gallup.com, accessed on July 17, 2025, https://www.gallup.com/workplace/349484/state-of-the-global-workplace.aspx
[15] From obligation to motivation: why employee engagement is the key to ESG success, accessed on July 17, 2025, https://www.weforum.org/stories/2024/12/employee-engagement-esg/
[16] Workplace ESG: How ESG Factors Shape Employee Engagement | Great Place To Work®, accessed on July 17, 2025, https://www.greatplacetowork.com/resources/blog/workplace-esg-environmental-social-governance-employee-experience
[17] ESG worker preferences study | PwC, accessed on July 17, 2025, https://www.pwc.com/gx/en/issues/workforce/pwcs-global-workforce-sustainability-study.html
[18] ESG worker preferences study | PwC, accessed on July 17, 2025, https://www.pwc.com/gx/en/issues/workforce/pwcs-global-workforce-sustainability-study.html
[19] The 8 Key Reasons Behind Corporate Failure in Engaging Employees in Sustainability, accessed on July 17, 2025, https://2030.builders/8-key-reasons-behind-corporate-failure-in-engaging-employees-in-sustainability/
[20] 4 reasons fewer employees are engaged in sustainability, and what to do about it – GreenBiz, accessed on July 17, 2025, https://trellis.net/article/4-reasons-fewer-employees-are-engaged-sustainability-and-what-do-about-it/
[21] The evolution of responsible business – Trellis Group, accessed on July 17, 2025, https://trellis.net/article/evolution-responsible-business/
[22] 3 paradigm shifts in corporate sustainability to new era of ESG | World Economic Forum, accessed on July 17, 2025, https://www.weforum.org/stories/2021/09/3-paradigm-shifts-in-corporate-sustainability-to-esg/
[24] Gain and sustain: Employee activism pushes orgs into the green – Insights2Action – Deloitte, accessed on July 17, 2025, https://action.deloitte.com/insight/3657/gain-and-sustain-employee-activism-pushes-orgs-into-the-green
[25] ATD Releases 2025 State of the Industry Report – Association for Talent Development, accessed on July 17, 2025, https://www.td.org/content/press-release/atd-research-optimism-remains-strong-for-future-of-learning-in-organizations
[26] General Training Sessions | case studies – sustain:able, accessed on July 17, 2025, https://www.esgable.com/case-studies/general-training-sessions
[27] ESG Training for Employee Engagement – Third Partners, accessed on July 17, 2025, https://thirdpartners.com/services/esg-training-employee-engagement/
[28] For Skeptics of Sustainable Messaging Salish Sea Consulting, accessed on July 17, 2025, https://www.salishseaconsulting.com/blog/sustainable-messaging
[29] Workplace ESG: How ESG Factors Shape Employee Engagement | Great Place To Work®, accessed on July 17, 2025, https://www.greatplacetowork.com/resources/blog/workplace-esg-environmental-social-governance-employee-experience
[30] How Sustainability and ESG Initiatives Impact Corporate Culture | Stanton Chase, accessed on July 17, 2025, https://www.stantonchase.com/insights/blog/how-sustainability-and-esg-initiatives-impact-corporate-culture
